Offering Personalized Service, Always.
With more than 35 years of experience we specialize in helping South Jersey find the right coverage at the right price.
We don’t work for an insurance company; we work for our clients. With us it’s not one size fits all. We can help find the right solution for you and your family.
1. Tell us about yourself.
Talk with one of our experienced and friendly agents about your needs and priorities.
2. We shop around for you.
We’ll compare policies from many of the best insurance companies in New Jersey.
3. A custom fit.
We customize your coverage to suit your needs and your budget.
4. Enjoy your peace of mind.
Relax knowing you and your loved ones are protected with an agency you can trust.
Laura Clement
18:59 18 Jul 25
I Highly recommend Mullica Hill Insurance! They have been a huge help in finding affordable homeowners insurance for my family. They are very friendly and very responsive. When there was a billing issue with my title company, they took care of it right away and helped resolve the issue. It’s rare these days to receive quick and easy customer service like that. Thank you Jill and Stephen!
Jose Ortiz
15:22 03 Apr 25
Steve took the time to explain my new homeowners insurance coverage and answered all my questions in detail. He also found me the best policy with all the coverages I was asking for. Everything I was interested in including a great rate!
J Roth
19:12 26 Mar 25
Very knowledgeable and took the time to answer all our questions and provide the details we requested.
Edward McKeever
14:32 26 Jan 24
The group is extremely knowledgeable and was able to find the right coverage for a much better price than I was paying. I would highly recommend discussing your policies with them as you approach renewal to ensure you are getting the right coverage for the right price.
Sherri Hand
22:24 04 Jan 24
We were unsatisfied with our current homeowners policy. We were expecting a rate decrease after getting a brand new roof, but instead our cost was going to increase so we decided to shop around for coverage with a local broker.
Steve Dornewass responded to our online inquiry for homeowners insurance. We knew we were over-paying for our current coverage, but didn't realize how outrageously expensive our current coverage was until Steve presented us with other options. He found a much more comprehensive policy with a highly rated insurer....with a premium savings of about 45%!!
He took care of everything! He secured the coverage and worked directly with our mortgage company.
If you are looking for a highly responsive insurance broker who listens to your needs, and is committed to customer service, you can't go wrong with Steve Dornewass and his team!
Steve Dornewass responded to our online inquiry for homeowners insurance. We knew we were over-paying for our current coverage, but didn't realize how outrageously expensive our current coverage was until Steve presented us with other options. He found a much more comprehensive policy with a highly rated insurer....with a premium savings of about 45%!!
He took care of everything! He secured the coverage and worked directly with our mortgage company.
If you are looking for a highly responsive insurance broker who listens to your needs, and is committed to customer service, you can't go wrong with Steve Dornewass and his team!
Sean Barry
16:00 13 Apr 23
Our insurance agent Stephen was very helpful in answering all of our questions (and we had a lot). He provided great direction as far as procedure in binding a new policy and cancelling an old policy. He was also very responsive via email and phone. I highly recommend this insurance agent to any and all looking for a new insurance policy!
Anthony Martin
14:37 28 Dec 22
Excellent courteous and prompt service.
Steve was understanding of my concerns and acted to my complete satisfaction.
Highly recommend Steve and his agency.
Steve was understanding of my concerns and acted to my complete satisfaction.
Highly recommend Steve and his agency.
M P
21:46 19 Nov 22
I have been very pleased with the attention to detail and the timeliness of various members of Mullica Hill Insurance during the last few years. Recently, Emma Dornewass was able to find a much lower-cost insurer with the same level of coverage as our existing policies. She provided excellent support in transitioning our three insurance policies to the other carrier without any lapses in coverage. Thanks!
Our Partners View All
